"He who represents himself has a fool for a client" ...

is a quote most often attributed to Abraham Lincoln, who was, himself, a lawyer. And, of course, there is some truth to that statement, many attorneys recognize that they may not be their own best choice in handling their own legal matter. Even as qualified attorneys, their legal specialty, experience, and knowledge may not be sufficient. For example, a corporate attorney handling his own divorce, may be a very bad idea. Also, the personal nature of family legal matters means that emotions can be at an all time high.

However, for many people in Florida, hiring an attorney is simply not an option. The cost of representation is out of reach. Many people would prefer to hire an attorney if they could, but have no choice but to proceed pro se. The barriers that pro se litigants must overcome are substantial, as the court system has a profound bias against self-represented parties -- even though around 70% of litigants in Florida family courts are, in fact, pro se.

Florida legal document preparers attempt to bridge the gap by offering document preparation services to pro se litigants. Professionally prepared documents and information about procedural rules can go a long way in helping consumers navigate the court system.

However, just as there is a strong bias against pro se litigants, there is also a strong bias against legal document preparers. Legal document preparers face frequent harassment from attorneys and the Florida Bar. It is my belief that the attorneys who attack and malign legal document preparers do so because they are at the bottom of the pack. The attorneys who attack and malign document preparers are threatened by the very existence of document preparers. They fear that consumers will turn to document preparers for their simple uncontested legal matters. And rightly so. Why does anyone need an attorney for a simple uncontested matter anyway?

Document preparation and lawyering are two completely different ball games. Theoretically, although different ball games, we both want a positive outcome for the consumers we serve.

Strike One:

I have had a couple of recent run ins with attorneys for needlessly and publicly denigrating document preparers in general. One of these run ins was on linkedin and some other document preparers saw it, and some of those document preparers also posted comments. The attorney made statements that document preparers are at best incompetent and at worst perpetrating fraud. I disagreed. He then quoted me the Florida Bar UPL rules. I acknowledged that I am well aware of our limitations regarding UPL. Then several document preparers also commented, stating that they frequently refer customers to attorneys, and in turn attorneys frequently refer consumers to them. That attorney ultimately removed his post and all the comments along with it.

I do have some sympathy for attorneys. They have painted themselves into a corner. Law schools have lowered standards considerably; and there are now something like 94,000 attorneys in Florida. And with a Florida adult population of around 16 million - that's around one attorney to every 170 Florida adults. Since many people never need an attorney, that could be some slim pickins. Also, attorneys have monumental self-induced PR problems. I don't go out of my way to malign attorneys,

And as the attorney on linkedin discovered, I don't appreciate attorneys going out of their way to malign document preparers.

Strike Two:

We recently came across an attorney site advertising family law document preparation. The attorney site states:

"Divorce is never trouble-free, but why make it harder than you have to?

For simple, uncontested cases, it’s as low as $399, and we make it as easy as 1, 2, 3:

• We’ll give you Florida Supreme Court approved forms absolutely free
• You’ll fill out the forms
• You’ll meet one-on-one with a member of our legal team to review the forms after you complete them

It’s that simple.  We’ll also explain local Court rules and give you advice about filing your case and appearing before the Court.  Plus, we’ll also provide a Notary Public service for free!

 

The clerk’s office charges fees for the necessary Florida Supreme Court approved forms and doesn’t even provide assistance when filling them out.

..., we give you the forms for free and our attorneys provide legal advice for a nominal fee".

So apparently the consumer has the pleasure of paying $399 to prepare the forms themselves. For that $399 they get handed a stack of forms, go home, fill them out, come back and review them with a "member of their legal team", who I'm guessing is a paralegal. In the real world, the forms are free, all the Supreme Court approved forms are free. Patting themselves on the back for giving away what is free seems a bit disingenuous to me. Notary services can also be free. Most banks offer free notary services to their customers providing no witness is required. Then comes the kicker the undisclosed "nominal fee". Who knows what constitutes a nominal fee in attorney world?

Strike Three:

Another family attorney site claimed the following. I do not include the site, as I do not want to provide him with free advertising. However, if you message me I'll send you the link and you can see for yourself. The site boldly claims:

We want to put the document preparation companies out of business.

"They aren't lawyers. They haven't the foggiest idea about Florida divorce law. Most are from out of state. They sell access to a software program that fills in blanks on a form. No lawyers. No real help. Mostly they get it wrong. Mostly they don't include all of the required papers. They charge too much. Some are practicing law without a license, which is a 5 year felony in Florida. The Florida Bar goes after some of them but doesn't have the manpower to shut them all down. Cyberspace can be hard to get a handle on. We aim to put them out of business, which is why we are charging so little."

This little paragraph is chock full of lies and disinformation. I won't even dignify the comments with an answer. This is a shame for consumers. Adding to consumers' confusion as to what to do and how to navigate the legal system is a true disservice.

You're OUT!

The silver lining for pro se litigants is that despite their lack of knowledge of the law, they are their own best experts on their case. It is the pro se litigant's life. To an attorney it is just another case.